5 Telltale Signs It's Time to Use AI to Mitigate Risk on Your Portfolios
October 13, 2023
•
5 mins read
One of the biggest challenges in risk monitoring is sifting through mountains of irrelevant data. Whether you're using search engines, financial news platforms, or even specialized in-house analytics, you end up with too much noise. Scrolling through to page 12 of Google is not only time-consuming, but leaves you with the nagging feeling that you could still be missing something.
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is a hot topic, with new breakthroughs and possible applications popping up every day. The question is no longer simply “can AI help me with that?” but rather “how can I use AI to help with that?” For Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) controversy and risk monitoring, AI is used to sift through enormous data sets at unparalleled speeds, bringing critical insights to the forefront faster and more efficiently than humanly possible.
When there are hundreds of companies to monitor, for example in a large investment portfolio or a group of suppliers, the advantages of AI are obvious. But what about smaller portfolios? How do you know it’s time to start using AI? Based on our experience working with private equity firms, asset managers and commercial banks, we’ve pulled together five signs that it’s time to consider AI.
1. Overwhelmed by Data: There's Too Much Noise
An AI-powered tool filters out the noise, even in situations where seemingly only humans would be able to do it, giving you the peace of mind that there’s no controversy lurking in the dark corners of the web. All of the key information is gathered in one place, ready for you to evaluate and decide the best course of action.
2. Difficulty Finding Critical Information: The Black Hole of Private Companies
On the flip side - sometimes instead of finding too much data, you can’t find any data at all. For private companies, information can be scarce, especially for smaller companies based overseas, where the only news coverage is local and in the local language. In this case, ESG ratings agencies often aren’t able to fill the gap either. There are millions of firms worldwide and less than 50,000 of them are covered by rating agencies (source).
AI, on the other hand, enables systematic coverage and statistically relevant results without human intervention, analyzing millions of websites and providing coverage on millions of public & private companies. If you are struggling to find information on a company, AI might be the answer.
3. Can't Accurately Analyze an Event: The Context is Missing
Beyond the actual controversy or event itself, understanding the context and history around it is essential for risk assessment. Is this a one-off concern or part of a recurring pattern? To get the full picture, you need to take a closer look not only at the company in question, but the key players, i.e. key executives, and the industry as a whole to understand if this is within the norms.
AI has an important role to play here also. By simply expanding the search, AI can provide you with a full picture of the controversy, including a quick summary and a benchmark against competitors in just a matter of minutes.
4. Missed Critical Window for Action: The Cost of Inefficiency
Markets can change quickly - and it’s only getting worse as information is spreading faster and more widely. The more time it takes you to gather and analyze information, the less time you have to react. This can be a challenge whether you are monitoring 30 companies or 100’s. If you find yourself trapped in a cycle of reacting to news rather than acting proactively, AI can help. Because AI scans and analyzes information in seconds, the alerts to potential controversies are in near real-time, allowing you as much time as possible to take action.
5. Missing ESG Expertise: The Knowledge Gap
To top it all off, ESG is complex and constantly evolving. Understanding what data is relevant and how to evaluate it requires real expertise. ESG rating agencies provide some guidance, but they typically leverage self-reported data - which is naturally biased. Take greenwashing for example where a company misleads its stakeholders, investors, and consumers about its environmental practices by communicating positive environmental performance contrary to its actual, less positive execution. It’s difficult to identify greenwashing using self-reported data.
Because AI relies on external stakeholders, such as online forums or news sources, it offers an unbiased take on a company’s ESG performance. Additionally, by choosing an AI with ESG expertise built-in, you benefit from an expert analysis without increasing the burden on your team.
As the speed and amount of information available continues to grow, AI offers a scalable way to monitor your partners, suppliers and portfolio. To learn more and find out if AI is a good fit for your company, contact our experts at SESAMm.
By Magnus Billing, SESAMm advisor, with insights from Sylvain Forté, CEO of SESAMm
Investors have faced so-called “black swan” events throughout history: unexpected crises with severe consequences, often rationalized only in hindsight. Yet in an era defined by generative AI and vast, real-time data lakes, the question arises: could such events be understood and acted upon before they unfold?
The 2023 U.S. regional banking crisis offers a striking case study. The rapid collapses of Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank revealed how quickly stress can spread and how difficult it remains to connect early warning signs across sources.
While traditional financial analysis focuses on fundamentals such as capital ratios, liquidity positions, governance, and earnings, a new class of tools is expanding the lens. AI-driven controversy data aggregates and analyzes millions of public sources, from regulatory statements to media and industry discussions, to detect emerging issues as they surface. It does not replace quantitative and fundamental analysis; it complements it by tracking the visibility of risk as it enters public conversation.
This combination of approaches may offer investors a fuller picture: the structural risks visible in balance sheets, and the narrative risks revealed through public dialogue. To test this idea, we revisited the 2023 crisis through both perspectives, starting with what traditional analysis could have shown and what it missed.
Traditional Analysis and Its Blind Spots
In hindsight, the vulnerabilities of regional banks such as Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank were visible before the start of 2023. Unrealized losses on long-term securities, heavy reliance on uninsured deposits, and exposure to interest-rate risk pointed to potential liquidity stress. Yet these indicators were neither fully recognized nor connected in the market.
Traditional analysis has a tendency to evaluate banks based on their specific niches: Silicon Valley Bank focused on technology and venture financing, while Signature Bank served commercial real estate and digital asset clients. However, this approach risks overlooking the common and shared structural factors: concentrated depositor bases, high sensitivity to interest rate changes, rapid growth, and weaknesses in governance. Few, if any, observers recognized how rapidly these vulnerabilities could interact and escalate in a modern, digitalized banking environment.
While financial reports contained the data, there was little discussion connecting these risks in the public domain. But what about controversy data? Would it have caught the impending crisis? To find out, I asked Sylvain Forté, CEO of SESAMm, to provide an AI perspective.
What the Data Showed: Signature Bank
Signature Bank displayed a gradual pattern of emerging risk visible through public discussion. From mid-2022 onward, controversy data showed a rise in coverage related to governance practices, management oversight, and deposit concentration risks, often in the context of its ties to the digital-asset industry.
Importantly, it was not the crypto exposure itself that led to the bank’s collapse. The bank even announced in December 2022 that it would reduce its crypto-related business. Instead, the FDIC’s Supervision of Signature Bank report concluded that, “the root cause of SBNY’s failure was poor management. SBNY’s board of directors and management pursued rapid, unrestrained growth without developing and maintaining adequate risk management practices and controls.”
From a controversy perspective, those signals were publicly visible but fragmented. As shown in the chart above, AI-powered monitoring could have aggregated them into a clear view of a sustained drift in governance-related discussions, offering an early indication that oversight and internal controls were under pressure and risk was increasing.
What the Data Missed: Silicon Valley Bank
In contrast, Silicon Valley Bank presented a markedly different pattern. While controversy data registered some activity in late 2022, including investor reactions to financial forecasts and coverage of routine business operations, these signals were fundamentally different in character from Signature Bank's governance-related warnings.
The September 2022 increase reflected market disappointment with financial guidance rather than operational or governance concerns. The subsequent activity captured normal business news, such as arranging syndicated loans. Critically, there was minimal public discussion of the bank's balance-sheet structure, unrealized losses, or depositor concentration risk until the crisis was already unfolding in March 2023.
This example underscores a key distinction: AI controversy monitoring excels at capturing reputational, governance, and operational risks as they enter public dialogue, but may not surface structural financial risks that remain confined to regulatory filings and analyst reports.
Lessons from Both Cases
The contrast between these two banks illustrates the complementary roles of quantitative and fundamental financial analysis vs AI-driven controversy monitoring.
In Signature Bank’s case, controversy data captured a steady accumulation of governance-related warnings, a slow build-up of risk visible through public discussion.
In Silicon Valley Bank’s case, the risks were structural but not yet discussed, leaving little for AI-powered controversy data to detect.
As Sylvain explains, “AI controversy monitoring helps investors understand how and when risks start to emerge in public dialogue. It does not replace fundamental analysis. It complements it by showing when the conversation begins to shift.”
Conclusion
Black swan events are often rationalized only in hindsight, but the 2023 regional banking crisis suggests a more nuanced reality. Some signals existed. What remained difficult was connecting them across sources before stress became contagion.
AI-driven controversy monitoring proved effective at surfacing governance and operational risks as they entered public dialogue, as Signature Bank demonstrated. Yet structural financial vulnerabilities like those at Silicon Valley Bank may not generate discussion until crisis forces the conversation, underscoring that no single lens captures all risk.
The advantage lies not in prediction, but in preparation: combining the structural risks visible in balance sheets with the narrative risks revealed through public discourse. In an era of real-time data and generative AI, the question is no longer whether information exists, but whether investors can connect it before it becomes consensus.
Reach out to SESAMm
TextReveal’s web data analysis of over five million public and private companies is essential for keeping tabs on ESG investment risks. To learn more about how you can analyze web data or to request a demo, reach out to one of our representatives.
SESAMm's ESG data shows FIFA's Controversy Exposure Score has stayed High to Very High since 2020. See why continuous monitoring beats the four-year cycle.
With the 2026 World Cup now underway, FIFA is back in the global spotlight, and its risk profile is once again being narrated in four-year cycles, as though controversy arrives with the tournament and recedes with the closing ceremony. The data points to a different pattern. Across the period from January 2020 to June 2026, the large majority of FIFA's most serious controversies were recorded outside any World Cup window. Tournaments concentrate global attention on FIFA's existing liabilities, but the evidence suggests they do not drive the underlying volume. Many of the substantive events, including court verdicts, regulator rulings, fund decisions, and bid matters, occur in the periods between tournaments.
For investors, sponsors, and anyone screening exposure to football's governing body, this distinction matters. If controversy were cyclical, it could be assessed around the calendar. Because the data indicates it is closer to continuous, it is better suited to ongoing monitoring. To examine this, the analysis below draws on SESAMm's controversy data, which captures and classifies FIFA's reputational, regulatory, and operational controversies.
Context: How FIFA's Structure Shapes Its Risk
Controversy Exposure Over Time
*Unsolicited ratings - produced from public sources, not commissioned by the rated company. For more information, visit here.
It helps to start with how FIFA is organized, because its governance structure has a direct bearing on the type of risk it carries. As a Swiss-law association, FIFA answers to a membership rather than to shareholders or a securities regulator, and its decision-making body, the FIFA Council, is composed of representatives from the regional confederations whose commercial interests the Council also oversees. This means the regulatory functions of sanctioning, eligibility, and integrity sit close to the commercial function of awarding and selling tournaments. Arrangements of this kind tend to produce a steady stream of governance-related questions as part of normal operations, which is consistent with SESAMm’s controversy data.
One useful illustration is procedural rather than criminal. The Blatter and Platini proceedings span the entire time period without reaching a clear resolution, running from a 2020 complaint through a fraud indictment, an acquittal, a prosecutorial appeal, and a second acquittal, before Platini opened a fresh action against FIFA and Infantino in June 2026. As a corruption narrative, the sequence is inconclusive. As a governance observation, it illustrates a broader dynamic in which matters are litigated and re-litigated over long periods, in part because resolution often depends on external courts operating on their own timelines. The result is a long-running procedural footprint rather than discrete, time-bound events.
The CES is an aggregate, entity-level score (0–100) that measures an entity's overall exposure to ESG controversies over time. It's built from individual ESG events and their intensities, synthesizing both event volume and severity into a single trackable figure. The intensity score, by contrast, operates one level down: it's applied at the event level, measuring how severe or important each individual ESG event is on a scale from 1 (least severe) to 5 (most severe). In short, the CES tells you how exposed an entity is overall, while the intensity score tells you how serious each underlying event is.
ESG Risk Over Time
This chart tracks FIFA's ESG controversies per year from 2020 to 2026, stacked by risk pillar. Governance dominates every bar, with social forming a secondary band and environmental barely visible. Volume climbs from a governance-heavy opening year to a clear peak in 2022, then holds at a stable plateau through 2025 before the short 2026 bar. The shape is driven by a handful of major events. The 2020 corruption investigations kept the opening-year baseline elevated and were almost purely governance-related, following a US DOJ indictment unsealed that April, which alleged bribes were paid for the votes that awarded Russia and Qatar the 2018 and 2022 World Cups.
The 2022 Qatar World Cup marked the clear inflection point, drawing sportswashing accusations and pushing total controversies to their peak, while migrant-worker conditions and human-rights coverage around Qatar thickened the social band into a permanent quarter-to-third of each bar from 2022 onward. Rather than reverting, controversies settled into a post-2022 "new normal," plateauing well above the pre-tournament level.
Underneath it all, corruption-and-bribery and legal/investigative exposure account for the bulk of total risk across 2020 to 2026, while environmental risk stays statistically negligible throughout.
ESG Risk by Type
Environmental Risks
Environmental risk accounts for a small share of FIFA's total controversy volume, but that low frequency masks cases of genuine severity. The Swiss Fairness Commission ruled against FIFA's Qatar 2022 carbon-neutrality marketing, turning a greenwashing accusation into a formal regulatory matter still active in June 2026. Related controversies extend the theme, including criticism of the Saudi Aramco and Coca-Cola sponsorships, the cooling and water-use controversies at Qatar, and the animal-welfare outcry over stray-dog culling ahead of Morocco's 2030 hosting.
Beyond these, FIFA has drawn criticism over its marketing and communications, notably branding the 2022 Qatar World Cup as "carbon neutral," and has dealt with fraud and embezzlement, exemplified by the case of former FIFA and CONCACAF official Chuck Blazer. Issues tied to its board and senior management leadership round out the picture, though the overall pattern is one of an organization reacting to the weight of its legal and ethical past rather than getting ahead of it.
As the breakdown above shows, the overwhelming majority of FIFA's screened ESG events fall into the low-risk tier (1,294, or 88.1%), with 165 (11.2%) on the watchlist and 9 (0.6%) classified as Violator, the highest-risk tier under SESAMm's UN Global Compact screening. That tier is assigned only where there is clear evidence of a breach, such as formal sanctions, court findings, or regulatory condemnations, rather than unresolved allegations. For investors with SFDR Article 8 or 9 obligations, or internal exclusion policies tied to UNGC compliance, a Violator flag on a core holding or counterparty is a material signal rather than a monitoring note, which is why the profile is best read as governance-led: the nine Violator events reflect adjudicated breaches concentrated in FIFA's governance history, not the live controversies surrounding the current tournament.
The composition that emerges is a governance core of long-running legal cases, a Qatar-rooted social overlay that has proven durable, and a small but genuinely high-severity environmental tail now being contested through formal channels.
Both lines explode together, but unevenly: absolute volume roughly doubles while the relative share more than quadruples, briefly making Qatar roughly one in seven of all FIFA-related items, because nearly every controversy fires at once. The spike packs in wider labor abuses, and the jailing of whistleblower Abdullah Ibhais; the OneLove armband ban and Qatar's criminalization of same-sex relations and the broader sportswashing and carbon-neutral greenwashing charges; and the unresolved bribery allegations over the 2010 hosting vote. On its own, this acute cluster would suggest a controversy that lives and dies with the tournament.
Phase 3: Off-Season Accumulation (2023–2026)
This is where the two lines part ways, and the accumulation shows itself. After the tournament, the relative share deflates sharply in 2023, the acute spike clearing, but it never returns to baseline; instead, it grinds steadily upward every subsequent year, ending in 2026 at roughly four-and-a-half times its pre-tournament level. Over the same stretch, the absolute volume collapses, from 1.43M in 2023 to around 448K in 2026, under a fifth of the 2022 peak. The two movements together are the key finding: even as total FIFA coverage shrank dramatically, the Qatar migrant-worker case captured a larger and larger share of what remained. Driving that residual are post-tournament findings: The non-payment of the migrant workers during the 2022 World Cup, the campaign for a migrant-worker compensation and remedy fund, and Amnesty's continued push for FIFA to fund remediation.A storyline that merely echoes the event would fade with the falling volume; one that accumulates does the opposite. The controversy is no longer powered by the match calendar but by its own momentum.
The Case Underneath
Underneath that residual sits the report's single heaviest case: the human-rights strand of 135 events running from 2020 to 2026, the longest-running and most densely populated case in the dataset. What stops it fading is that each turn of the hosting cycle reactivates it: the 2026 uptick to 6.49%, the highest reading outside the tournament year itself, coincides with the 2026 World Cup now underway in North America, which revives retrospective scrutiny of Qatar, and the emerging human-rights questions around Saudi Arabia's 2034 tournament, which carries the same migrant-labour lens straight to the next host. The case is not simply failing to fade; it is being actively topped up by each new host, which is why the social exposure reads as structural rather than event-bound.
Key Takeaways
Taken together, the data describes a profile that is primarily governance-related, with the most severe and persistent cases concerning legal exposure, corruption, and bribery, supported by a durable Qatar-rooted social overlay and a small but high-severity environmental tail. All three pillars reach maximum case intensity, so severity is not confined to any single dimension.
The most consistent feature is persistence. FIFA's Controversy Exposure Score has remained in the High-to-Very-High band throughout the period and sits at 99 today. The largest cases run continuously from 2020 to 2026, and a significant share of binding decisions occur outside tournament windows. None of this reduces the significance of the World Cup, which clearly concentrates attention and scrutiny. But the underlying controversy is produced across the quarters between tournaments, and several of FIFA's most consequential outcomes are set during lower-attention periods. For those screening FIFA, the practical implication is that continuous monitoring suits this profile better than event-triggered review, because much of the relevant activity occurs between tournaments rather than during them.
The data suggests that for an entity like FIFA, a four-year review cycle misses most of what matters. Request a demo to see how SESAMm supports the kind of ongoing monitoring this profile requires.
*The Controversy Exposure Score (CES) is a continuous score from 0 to 100 measuring a company's exposure to ESG controversies over time, based on the severity of incidents and their media volume. This is an unsolicited rating: it is not commissioned by the rated company. The company is notified before its score is first issued, does not take part in the rating, and SESAMm has no access to its management or non-public documents. Ratings are produced only from public and licensed sources. The methodology is available here.
In an era where global supply chains span continents and consumer goods can travel through dozens of hands before reaching store shelves, the challenge of ensuring ethical production has never been more complex. Against this backdrop, the recent warning from Parliament's Joint Committee on Human Rights should serve as a wake-up call for policymakers, businesses, and consumers alike.
The committee's stark assessment that the UK risks becoming a "dumping ground" for goods made using forced labor comes at a critical juncture. As other major economies implement increasingly stringent measures to block exploitative products from their markets, Britain's relatively lax approach threatens to make it an attractive destination for goods that can no longer find entry elsewhere.
The Hidden Reality of Modern Supply Chains
The scale of forced labor in global supply chains is both vast and largely invisible to end consumers. When we purchase everyday items, from clothing and electronics to food products, few consider the working conditions of those who produce them. Yet the uncomfortable truth is that forced labor affects virtually every industry and touches supply chains that ultimately reach consumers.
The British Joint Committee on Human Rights has identified a critical vulnerability: while other nations strengthen their regulatory frameworks to combat forced labor imports, the UK appears to be falling behind.¹ This regulatory gap creates a concerning dynamic where goods rejected by more stringent markets could increasingly find their way to British shores.
International Developments and Competitive Disadvantage
The committee's findings become particularly significant when viewed against recent international developments. Major economies have been implementing increasingly robust measures to prevent forced labor goods from entering their markets, creating higher barriers for ethically questionable products. This trend places the UK in a precarious position, potentially becoming the path of least resistance for exploitative goods seeking entry into Western markets.
The economic implications extend beyond moral considerations. British businesses operating in global markets face growing pressure to demonstrate ethical supply chain practices. Companies that cannot adequately address forced labor risks may find themselves at a competitive disadvantage as international standards continue to evolve.
The Committee's Clear Recommendations
The parliamentary committee's primary recommendation, implementing import bans on goods linked to forced labor, represents a significant departure from the UK's current approach. The existing framework, which relies heavily on voluntary corporate reporting and due diligence measures, has proven insufficient to address the scale and complexity of modern forced labor.
This recommendation aligns with best practices emerging globally. Governments are taking more direct action to prevent exploitative goods from entering their markets. The question is no longer whether such measures are necessary but how quickly they can be implemented effectively.
Practical Challenges and Solutions
Implementing comprehensive anti-forced labor measures presents genuine challenges, particularly for small and medium-sized enterprises that may lack the resources for extensive supply chain monitoring. However, these challenges should not deter action; they should inform the design of practical support systems.
Businesses need access to reliable tools and guidance for identifying forced labor risks in their supply chains. Government agencies, industry associations, and civil society organizations must collaborate to develop accessible resources that enable companies of all sizes to participate meaningfully in ethical sourcing practices.
The Path Forward
The parliamentary committee's warning represents more than a policy recommendation; it calls for Britain to reclaim its position as a leader in human rights protection. The government faces a clear choice: implement robust measures to prevent forced labor goods from entering UK markets, or risk Britain becoming known as a soft touch on fundamental human rights issues.
The urgency of this situation cannot be overstated. Each day of delay potentially allows more exploitative goods to enter British supply chains and undermines our credibility in international human rights discussions. The time for voluntary approaches and gentle encouragement has passed; decisive action is now required.
SESAMm’s AI Technology Reveals ESG Insights
Discover unparalleled insights into ESG controversies, risks, and opportunities across industries. Learn more about how SESAMm can help you analyze millions of private and public companies using AI-powered text analysis tools.
Stay ahead with the latest in ESG and AI intelligence
Join our mailing list to receive new reports, event invites, and updates from SESAMm directly to your inbox.